HELP
tips, questions, how-tos for the undergrounds
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
Welcome to the HELP Underground. Come here if you have suggestions, need help, have a question, experiencing a problem. For private matters, message adam. HELP is where we collect all the feedback to make the Undergrounds happier, faster, and more enjoyable for everyone.

Remove mods abusing their mod roles

who's talking here?

adam 7
Cyber Victimizer 1
Shana 5
a1633uu 7
Polly Ester 1
Mrs Wallace 3
smartypants 2
FantabulousSparkes 2
Redsox 2
Bibble 1
Tiki No fo realz its me 1
RaeRie 1
KelJoY II 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

Only you Adam can see all that mods do.
It is obvious there mod abusing their mod roles. 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

The mods can see what the mods do.
The mods have power to remove mods. 

Polly Ester --- 16 years ago -

They can't see who ices who. 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

They can't see who ices who. 

True. That's a separate suggestion thread. :) 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

That is not going to work Adam. The mob mentality will not allow it to be fair.
You or an admin you elect have to govern the behavior of those abusing it. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

When the mods have formed a click then what? 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

When the mods have formed a click then what?

Revolution. 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

Nope, that's not working either.

Why as someone put it on KU throw the baby out with the bathwater?
You may have some good mods, but your answer is revolt? Then all the mods go and the whole disaster begins again. 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

The system assumes:
1. the people will elect generally good mods
2. if they elect a poor mod or two, then the good mods can remove them
3. if they elect a majority of poor mods, then the community can revolt and hold another election 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

The "system" has proven that it is not working.

And we know assuming does no good. 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

The "system" has proven that it is not working.

the theory is sound. tell me where it is breaking down. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

Revolution.

What % is required for a change? 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

What % is required for a change?

Enough that it's not easy. But not so much that it's impossible. The revolt occurs when the meter hits 100%. 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

Why as someone put it on KU throw the baby out with the bathwater?
You may have some good mods, but your answer is revolt? Then all the mods go and the whole disaster begins again.


thats the breakdown.

100%.

So in other words, until 100% of the members revolt, the mods remain the same? 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

double post 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

Enough that it's not easy. But not so much that it's impossible. The revolt occurs when the meter hits 100%.


Dose that mean it has to be unanimous?
With everyone on at the same time or not?
This sounds impossible if this is how I understand it. 

Mrs Wallace --- 16 years ago -

I realize you own these sites, Adam, and for you, it's just a "fun" experiment. However, consider the discord that's being caused because of it.

Would you want to post on your sites if you had no control over them? Do you think having moderators that flaunt their "powers", start threads to antagonize the people they've iced, etc, are being "good examples" for the community they're supposed to govern? 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

the theory is sound. tell me where it is breaking down.

Your theory is wrong. You assume most people will behave themselves (i.e. people will elect good mods, mods will police themselves), when what you have is a majority with no self restraint and/or empathy, at least on KU, because this is the internet.

By this time, you must know the people who are civil. Delegate some of the work to them, if they are willing? 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

Adam, please value the good mods you have.
You can see more than anyone those abusing their privileges.
By doing nothing, you are making things much more difficult for the mods who in fact are doing a good job.
You said you don't have the time to govern all the sites, but if you would devote the time you do have to listening to the decent mods, the ones who you can see have done a good job thus far, you will be showing your support to them.
Some have quit modding all together as it has become futile. (your older mods)
Why bother if the owner of the site does not support or do what is right?
It is not an easy task, modding, show your support to those who are willing to help you make your site what you envisioned it to be.
we can go over this time and time again.
Bottom line, is the revolt is impossible by your standards,100% will never happen, and why penalize the good mods, toss them out only to start yet another election and start this farce all over again.
Get to know some of the mods you have entrusted to run your site.
Just review their actions. 

Redsox --- 16 years ago -

Enough that it's not easy. But not so much that it's impossible. The revolt occurs when the meter hits 100%.

How is it possible to reach 100% when our revolt was at 70% the other day and is now at 20%? Interesting that its counting down rather than up. 

Mrs Wallace --- 16 years ago -

How is it possible to reach 100% when our revolt was at 70% the other day and is now at 20%? Interesting that its counting down rather than up.


Adam, that's an excellent question. How does the meter go back down? 

FantabulousSparkes --- 16 years ago -

Adam, that's an excellent question. How does the meter go back down?
Probably from one using multiple accounts hitting the button. 

Redsox --- 16 years ago -

Probably from one using multiple accounts hitting the button.

Each IP address can only revolt once. No matter what screen name you are logged into. I could have 10 different screen names and click away on each and it will still only register as one click. 

FantabulousSparkes --- 16 years ago -

Each IP address can only revolt once. No matter what screen name you are logged into. I could have 10 different screen names and click away on each and it will still only register as one click.
Maybe on revolt, but I know for voting Adam had to go in and take all the whack votes out. Most likely it is the same. Maybe not. 

Mrs Wallace --- 16 years ago -

So how does it go back down? Is it on a timer? If it hasn't had clicks in so many hours/days, it starts to disregard the clicks it's had? 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

Really, why do we have a consistant pot-stirrer, a repeat ice box offender who has no self restraint, and a RL stalker among our mods? How ridiculous is that? I'm sorry, but frankly, that seemed like a train wreck waiting to happen, after their election. And guess what? We got a train wreck. Just being honest.

My suggestion to Adam is get rid of those 3 and see what happens. Justify it however you like, you are the owner.

^^^^From another post. I couldn't agree more.

The people of ku have no say. Revolt or NOT! I had nothing to do with that popularity contest. Had I'd known? Everyone would have heard me make some noise. I was fine with the mods before. Why the previous mods were not happy or not? Should had been addressed by you Adam. You sould have showed a little appreciation an respect. Listened to what they had to say if they had a concerne with something or not. Now the Kuers are suffering the brunt of your lack of the ability to care and show your personal side. You owe it to the veterans of KU. The none offenders. The ethical ones who have more faith in this site than you do.

The mods who are the ones in question? Will end up costing you a great deal down the road if you do not address this quick! 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

My suggestion to Adam is get rid of those 3 and see what happens.

My suggestion to people that are frustrated with certain mods is to talk with the *good* mods and see what the mods can do to help them. They are more familiar with what is going on, and who is doing what. 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

Adam I have tried this.
As I have told before, 3-4 are in a cahoots, 3-4 dont care enough or are too busy.
We are also too busy.

YOU own the site. The effort you put into these "experiment" would be better served picking good mods, and weeding out the bad ones yourself. Support the decent ones, and delegate to the ones YOU see are doing good.

Any one with good business sense implements the same procedures.

The success of their bushiness depends on the quality of their employees. 

Bibble --- 16 years ago -

1 mod and friends trying to make other mods look bad could be their own social experiment to play you. all mods have friends these ppl are her friends. Y not show who ices who to all. 

Tiki No fo realz its me --- 16 years ago -

Dude FINALLY tries to do something to improve the U's and people still aren't happy. Shock of shocks. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

suggestions

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

HELP