HELP
tips, questions, how-tos for the undergrounds
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
Welcome to the HELP Underground. Come here if you have suggestions, need help, have a question, experiencing a problem. For private matters, message adam. HELP is where we collect all the feedback to make the Undergrounds happier, faster, and more enjoyable for everyone.

How revolutions work

who's talking here?

adam 6
debbie 7
Shana 2
a1633uu 5
Mrs Wallace 6
FantabulousSparkes 4
Redsox 1
Bibble 3
a1441550uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

Why do we have revolutions?

Revolutions are recourse for the community if the mods are failing at governing properly (mods get complacent, corrupt, or disappear). If enough people revolt, then a revolution occurs, the mods are removed, and an election is held.

How many people need to revolt?

It's a percentage of the community population, a complicated formula that we tweak as we watch and learn. 100% on the revolutometer does not mean 100% of the community. 100% on the revolutometer is the threshold that sparks a revolution. (For example, 100% on the revolutometer may be roughly equivalent to 50% of the community population revolting)

Why does the % go down?

The revolutometer is a measure of the *current* pulse of the community. A revolt vote decreases in weight as time goes on. Revolting again and again doesn't add revolt points, but it keeps your vote fresh. 

Redsox --- 16 years ago -


Why does the % go down?

The revolutometer is a measure of the *current* pulse of the community. A revolt vote decreases in weight as time goes on. Revolting again and again doesn't add revolt points, but it keeps your vote fresh.


Thats ridiculous. Especially since it will only allow each person to vote once. So if members vote over time that they want a revolution over time the meter decreases.. This doesnt permit a revolt since no one is permitted to try and revolt again once the meter goes down. In time no one will be able to revolt.

Ghey. 

Mrs Wallace --- 16 years ago -

It doesn't make sense, Adam. Not everyone is on the site at the same time.

Why wouldn't you make it so the clicks count as they're made and have it keep a running tally? If you want people to be able to change their mind, add an option to hit "UN-revolt". 

FantabulousSparkes --- 16 years ago -

Why wouldn't you make it so the clicks count as they're made and have it keep a running tally? If you want people to be able to change their mind, add an option to hit "UN-revolt".
One issue solved in my mind. Good thinking Mrs. Wallace. 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

So 100% on the people have to be on at that same time, and vote the same day 100% the same way to revolt?

Never happen.

Why would anyone revolt against ALL the mods?
Some are doing a decent job.

Only a select few should be removed.

And if, by some divine miracle the revolt does work, the process starts all over?
I don't see this as a positive thing at all. 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

This doesnt permit a revolt since no one is permitted to try and revolt again once the meter goes down.

You can click revolt as many times as you wish. Each time you click it, it sets the time on your revolt to "right now". So if you revolted a month ago, the value of the revolt is very little. Clicking revolt makes it *current* and so it carries more weight. 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

When does any of this end? 

Mrs Wallace --- 16 years ago -

Thanks, Fantabulous! :) 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

So 100% on the people have to be on at that same time, and vote the same day 100% the same way to revolt?

That's incorrect. Read the explanation again. 

Mrs Wallace --- 16 years ago -

adam, what's wrong with what I suggested instead of a somewhat confusing and convoluted system you have now? 

debbie --- 16 years ago -

So, what is the time frame between "votes" that will actually count or need to be "refreshed"? People will just stop voting because they will see their vote is futile. Why take an action that has no result or that you have to refresh at an invisible interval? It appears the revolt option is just to make people feel they have control over something they really don't. 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

adam, what's wrong with what I suggested instead of a somewhat confusing and convoluted system you have now?

It sounds more complicated than it is. :) The formula is complex, but the revolution in general is based on how people feel *right now* about how the mods are doing.

I might revolt today, because I see a problem, but then the mods might take action, so in a week I'm happy again. If I'm still unhappy, then I'll revolt again to keep it fresh. If enough other people are unhappy, then a revolution will occur. :) 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

The revolt thing makes no sense to me, JMO.

Why would you want to start the process all over again?
The drama will be non ending.
Why not just support the decent mods you already have and get rid of the ones abusing their privileges.
Honestly, it will take much less effort to weed them out, set some standards with new mods, and get to know the good mods, so you can then in turn delegate, freeing up your time.

The way things are set up now, obviously isn't working, how can it when people are allowed to vote in some of the offenders of your site rules? 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

It appears the revolt option is just to make people feel they have control over something they really don't.

They don't have control. If they are in the small minority. But if enough people are unhappy with them, then they gain enough control collectively to remove the mods and hold a new election. 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

We are like dogs chasing our tails here. :( 

debbie --- 16 years ago -

Sorry, Adam..not trying to be a downer, but most people can't even figure out how to post pictures or use the quote function. I think that the revolt system will be way over their heads and they will vote once and that's it.
Maybe that's the way you want it..for people to just give up and lose interest.

The system was doomed when people got to vote their like minded, gossipy friends to be in charge of the board anyway, instead of voting in the many decent, non-drama feeding posters that don't hang out with them at starbucks. **sigh** 

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

Why not just support the decent mods you already have and get rid of the ones abusing their privileges.

Why don't the good mods get rid of the poor ones? 

a1633uu --- 16 years ago -

Why don't the good mods get rid of the poor ones?

We've been over this again and again. Please listen and respect our feelings. 

Mrs Wallace --- 16 years ago -

I heart you, Debbie! Excellent post. :) 

FantabulousSparkes --- 16 years ago -

feelings.
What about other peoples feelings? You feelings may be different towards one then the next. That is why he put in place voting for the whole site majority rules and he takes out bad votes. 

Mrs Wallace --- 16 years ago -


Why don't the good mods get rid of the poor ones?


have you seen the dynamics on these websites, adam?

Are you at all aware that these people are friends who meet for coffee and lunches, etc? I don't know if it's peer pressure or what, but if these moderators are friends, they are NOT going to vote against their buddies, regardless of the situation. 

debbie --- 16 years ago -

Why don't the good mods get rid of the poor ones?


1) Because the "good" ones are outnumbered with the new election

2) Too many ramifications. everyone is in bed with each other, so to speak and real life social ostracizing has already,apparently, been a side effect of this new election. Just read the threads and see how it is going. 

Bibble --- 16 years ago -

Nothing but a bunch of friends of 1 mod that wants to bully everyone and lie to get mods out they don't like. 1 Mod wants her friends in so they lie about other mods. U did it right with elections. Ur site Ur rules. The bunch of them whining r the bullies on ku. 

debbie --- 16 years ago -

Nothing but a bunch of friends of 1 mod that wants to bully everyone and lie to get mods out they don't like.

lol. I rest my case. 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

Adam? Is this revolt thing something you created and are testing on KU? 

FantabulousSparkes --- 16 years ago -

KU?
I just wanted to note, your not the only site with the same issue. Just wanted to put that out there. 

Bibble --- 16 years ago -

I know I go to other sites. U probly got some of our pple. 

debbie --- 16 years ago -

KU?
I just wanted to note, your not the only site with the same issue. Just wanted to put that out there.


You're right. Some posting on this help site do not realize that this is a forum for all of the UGs and the posters are from all over the place. 

FantabulousSparkes --- 16 years ago -

You're right. Some posting on this help site do not realize that this is a forum for all of the UGs and the posters are from all over the place.
I just saw many saying KU and thought I would note that lol. Same issues on just about all the sites. 

Bibble --- 16 years ago -

on some of other UGs when Ur pple r banned they can't come back on. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

HELP